Retrieving the 'voices of the voiceless': Historiographical issues in writing the history of the chinese labour corps

Dendooven Dominiek

doi:10.47297/wspctWSP2515-470210.20220601

PDF
Export
Share
Collection
Album

Retrieving the 'voices of the voiceless': Historiographical issues in writing the history of the chinese labour corps

Volume 6, Issue 1

Views: 0 Downloads: 15

Retrieving the 'voices of the voiceless': Historiographical issues in writing the history of the chinese labour corps
Retrieving the 'voices of the voiceless': Historiographical issues in writing the history of the chinese labour corps
Flanders Fields Museum, Ypres 8900, Belgium
Vol. 6, Issue 1, Pages: 119-127(2022)
Published： 30 June 2022 ，
DOI：10.47297/wspctWSP2515-470210.20220601
Accepted：

Scan QR Code

.Retrieving the 'voices of the voiceless': Historiographical issues in writing the history of the chinese labour corps[J].Critical Theory,2022,06(01):119-127.
DOI：

.Retrieving the 'voices of the voiceless': Historiographical issues in writing the history of the chinese labour corps[J].Critical Theory,2022,06(01):119-127. DOI： 10.47297/wspctWSP2515-470210.20220601.

摘要

Abstract

While scholars have produced tens if not hundreds of thousands of books on the First World War

the Chinese Labour Corps has only wielded a relatively very small number of dedicated works. For this marginalization of the CLC in the historiography

three main reasons can be identified: the subordinate position in the social and military hierarchy of the time

the elevated number of illiterate members in the corps and as a consequence the lack of personal recollections

and boundaries of language and culture. However

these difficulties should not prevent researchers from entering this field of research. Working with bicultural and multilingual 'middlemen' and interpreting 'alternative sources' such as photos

film

objects

poetry

songs and oral history can offer different but rewarding routes to uncover the past of 'subordinate groups' such as the Chinese Labour Corps.

关键词

Keywords

Chinese labour corpsHistoriographyMethodologyCommemorationMemoirsMemoryTrench art

references

顾杏卿.«欧战工作回忆录»,第3版,长沙商务印书馆,1938.

加里•兰多尔.«克莱因的<与中国佬在一起>— 一本反历史之书»,见马骊编著:«一战华工在法国», 吉林出版集团有限责任公司, 2014:397-410.

杰若姆•比泰.«华工的凹凸版、黑白刻字—苏瓦松地区的中国及远东遗迹»,见马骊编著:«一战华工在法国», 吉林出版集团有限责任公司, 2014:367-379.

马春苓.« 游欧杂志», «潍坊文化通鉴», 山东友谊书社, 1992:792.

尼古拉斯•桑德斯.«一次大战与华工战壕艺术»,见马骊编著:«一战华工在法国», 吉林出版集团有限责任公司, 2014:380-394.

孙干.«华工记»,见齐德智整理,«一战华工欧战纪实»,天津社会科学院出版社,2013.

Boniface X. (2010). Portraits de la Grande Guerre – les Pastels d'Eugène Burnand au Musée de la Légion d'honneur. Paris, ECPAD.

Buttet J. (2012). 'En creux, en relief et en noir, souvenirs de Chine et d'Extrême-Orient dans le Soissonnais'. In : MA Li (Ed.) Les travaillaurs chinois en France dans la Première Guerre mondiale. Paris, CNRS Editions, pp. 413-426.

Dendooven, D & Chielens, P (2008). World War I. Five Continents in Flanders. Tielt, Lannoo.

Dendooven, D & Vanhaelemeersch, P (2010). Gu Xingqing: mijn herinneringen als tolk voor de Chinese arbeiders in WO 1. Tielt, Lannoo.

Dendooven,D a.o. (2019). Dragons on the Western Front. Chinese trench art from the Collection of In Flanders Fields Museum [西线战场的龙—一战时期中国劳工的战壕艺术] (In Flanders Fields Museum Dossier 10). Ypres, in Flanders Fields Museum.

Dendooven D.(2021). Asia in Flanders Fields. Indians and Chinese on the western front, 1914-1920. Barnsley, Pen & Sword Military.

Dupouy A.(1919). Un Camp de Chinois. Revue de Paris, vol. 26, No 21, 146-162.

Hagen G.(1996). Eenen dwazen glimlach aan het front. Chinese koelies aan het westers front in de Eerste Wereldoorlog. KU Leuven, MA thesis Sinology.

McClune B.(2016). War! Hellish War! Star Shell Reflections 1916-1918. The Illustrated Great War Diaries of Jim Maultsaid. Barnsley, Pen & Sword Military.

McClune B.(2017). The dawn of victory - Thank you China. Star shell reflections 1918-1919. The Illustrated Great War Diaries of Jim Maultsaid. Barnsley, Pen & Sword Military.

Omissi D.(2014). Indian voices of the Great War: soldiers' letters, 1914-18. Gurgaon, Penguin Viking.

Saunders N. (2012). 'Travail et nostalgie sur le front de l'Ouest: l'Art des tranchées chinois et la Première Guerre mondiale'. In : MA Li (Ed.. Les travailleurs chinois en France dans la Première Guerre mondiale. Paris, CNRS Editions, pp. 427-442.

Sun Gan. (2017). Vive Labeur. Wedervaren van een Chinese arbeider in de Eerste Wereldoorlog. Veurne, Hannibal.

Taylor J.,& Denning I.(2016). Reflections of a Regiment. The Honourable Artillery Company and the Great War in Pictures. London, the Honourable Artillery Company & Third Millennium Publishing, 154-5.

Tchang, C.(n.d). Papa était chinois, maman berrichonne.

Wang-Kinki.(1920). Le chant des travailleurs chinois. La Politique de Pékin.

British Library (London), India Office Records, L/MIL/5/825-8.

The National Archives, London (TNA), WO 95, WO 107/37, WO 154/8.

Alert me when the article has been cited

Submit

Making a new China in the Chinese Labour Corps

Related Author

Dominiek Dendooven

Related Institution

the University of Antwerp

⁰